Meanwhile, Rowena arrives at the brothel where the sex for souls trade is headquartered
A young lady is chased down an alley by Raul. He catches her and she begs him not to hurt her, promising to come back. He grabs her, and she stabs him in the eye with one of her high heels. Raul then reveals his black eyes and breaks her neck.
Sam Dean are eating in a restaurant and Sam is looking through the paper for a case. Dean says there isn’t a case, that they stopped to get a good steak. When Dean’s phone starts “blowing up,” Sam grabs it to see what is going on. He discovers that Dean has a dating app, and that they came here so Dean could hook up with a woman. It turns out that the woman, Shaylene, is a sex worker, and she is willing to trade sex for Dean’s soul.
Crowley is not pleased, proclaims the sex trade is tacky and wants it cleaned up
Castiel Hannah continue to track down angels and return them to Heaven. When Hannah suddenly takes off her clothes to take a shower, Castiel is confused, and Hannah wants to know if her nakedness bothers Cas. As they are checking out of the hotel, Hannah is confronted by her vessel’s (Caroline Johnson) husband, Joe Johnson. He wants to know why she left, so Hannah explains that she is having an affair with Castiel. When Joe doesn’t believe her, she kisses Castiel, and then the two of them leave.
Crowley finds out about the sex for souls trade from Gerald, who had escaped Rowena’s attack
Dean wants to help Shaylene, so Sam Dean set a trap for her pimp, who is a demon. After catching him in a devil’s trap, they question the demon to find out how many girls are involved. Before he can answer, Shaylene kills the demon in a fit of anger so the boys have to track down clues elsewhere.
She kills Raul using an ancient hex, and then invites the working girls, Elle Catlin, to come along with her. Rowena wines dines the two sex workers in an attempt to get them to join her coven. She explains how the Grand Coven threw her out because her magic was too extreme so she was banned from taking students and forming her own coven. However, she wants to be their mentor. They agree, and as they leave the restaurant a waiter Rowena had hexed suddenly dies violently.
Sam and Dean find the brothel, and discover the gruesome body of Raul. When Sam finds a hex bag, they conclude that Raul jeevansathi sign up was killed by a witch. The boys research the hex used to kill Raul, and discover that a witch by the name of Rowena created it, and she was the only one that ever used it. Sam and Dean then investigate the dead waiter, who died in a similar manner as Raul. After talking with other hunters, who are aware of other such grisly murders in fancy hotels, Sam and Dean decide to check out all the 5 star hotels in the area.
Cole Trenton has captured a demon, and proceeds to torture it for any information on Dean. Hannah feels bad about lying to Joe because she didn’t want to hurt him. Castiel reassures her that she did the right thing because Joe had to move on. Castiel explains what happened to Jimmy Novak, concluding that the mission always comes first. However, Hannah decides that the right thing to do is to return to Heaven and let her vessel go back to her husband. This leads Castiel to look up Jimmy Novak online.